Went on Saturday 3/21/25 after church. We have been there before for their pizza and it is usually pretty good. This Saturday it was perfect!!! I think it was the best we ever had. The crust was cooked with a crispy crust that you could pick up the pieces without being soggy or floppy and not overcooked and burnt. Their dough and sauce is always very good. Wish I had taken a pic before we dug into it further. Whoever was cooking pizzas that night did very nice job. By the way, they don’t have a lot of staffing and the waitress hustles and does good. Allow a little patience.
Nichole Cohen
-
January 10, 2026
The pizza was good. The garlic rolls were eh. There was only one server and a full dining room so service was super slow. It was 15 minutes before we got water. It was nice sitting with my friends and talking but water and rolls right away would have been nice. Next time, we will just get takeout.
Teresa Gutierrez
-
April 28, 2026
This used to be one of our favorite restaurants—for my friend and her children, as well as for my own family. Brianna is a very kind young woman who is very attentive to service; however, last week, we unfortunately had to wait a very long time to be served, and our food arrived late—so late, in fact, that we ended up being the very last people to leave. When we finally did leave, they practically kicked us out; we truly felt that this was an act of racism. They spoke to us disrespectfully. It is a shame, because the venue and the food are good, but the person who treated us so poorly was racist.
Jon Sturdevant
-
April 06, 2023
We really liked the specialty pizzas! The maragharita pizza and the all meat pizza were delicious! We also tried the appetizer sampler and we really enjoyed the Italian style Rangoons! We'd never had anything like them before. Highly recommend you give them a try with your pizza!
J C
-
May 15, 2026
Placed online order they “never received it” because of the slice app not working correctly. If that’s the case and this is your business, wouldn’t you be reacting to it immediately? So there has been multiple situations that this has happened… it’s a bad look for them business wise, and I’m not even sure if they’re telling the truth, considering all the negative reviews on how slow they are and how lack of help they have. Ended up being 50 min. To get our pizza.
Our Address
2560 Glendale Ave, Green Bay, WI 54313, USA
Claim Listing: Josephine’s Pizza & Pastaria
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
Went on Saturday 3/21/25 after church. We have been there before for their pizza and it is usually pretty good. This Saturday it was perfect!!! I think it was the best we ever had. The crust was cooked with a crispy crust that you could pick up the pieces without being soggy or floppy and not overcooked and burnt. Their dough and sauce is always very good. Wish I had taken a pic before we dug into it further. Whoever was cooking pizzas that night did very nice job. By the way, they don’t have a lot of staffing and the waitress hustles and does good. Allow a little patience.
The pizza was good. The garlic rolls were eh. There was only one server and a full dining room so service was super slow. It was 15 minutes before we got water. It was nice sitting with my friends and talking but water and rolls right away would have been nice. Next time, we will just get takeout.
This used to be one of our favorite restaurants—for my friend and her children, as well as for my own family. Brianna is a very kind young woman who is very attentive to service; however, last week, we unfortunately had to wait a very long time to be served, and our food arrived late—so late, in fact, that we ended up being the very last people to leave. When we finally did leave, they practically kicked us out; we truly felt that this was an act of racism. They spoke to us disrespectfully. It is a shame, because the venue and the food are good, but the person who treated us so poorly was racist.
We really liked the specialty pizzas! The maragharita pizza and the all meat pizza were delicious! We also tried the appetizer sampler and we really enjoyed the Italian style Rangoons! We'd never had anything like them before. Highly recommend you give them a try with your pizza!
Placed online order they “never received it” because of the slice app not working correctly. If that’s the case and this is your business, wouldn’t you be reacting to it immediately? So there has been multiple situations that this has happened… it’s a bad look for them business wise, and I’m not even sure if they’re telling the truth, considering all the negative reviews on how slow they are and how lack of help they have. Ended up being 50 min. To get our pizza.