The waitress was the only redeeming quality about this place that was holding it back from been a complete terrible visit. She was apologetic and ended up getting it removed from our bill, very nice lady.
Our pizza was so thin it couldn't even be cooked properly, the dough already wasn't cooked thoroughly, still stretched apart and separated just trying to hold it.
I'm not sure if there's a pizza sauce shortage but it looks like they put the thinnest layer possible on top of layer of crust that looked thinner than a dime.
Our waitress was very apologetic, took it back to get it replaced which at first they just tried to reheat it, sending it back with everything on top burnt black but the dough was already a mess. They ended up making us a new one which was just as bad as the first.
In the first two pictures you can see the dough separating, third picture being the teaspoon of sauce on top of playdough consistency base, the final two pictures show the paper thin pizza. (This was the replacement pizza since the first one was worse)
Typically we have pretty good visits here too. But frozen pizza would top the stuff we were served any day.
Starman2112
-
June 28, 2026
I decided against this place after pulling pulling into the lot. I almost walked inside but noticed trash littered all over the sidewalk around the building and weeds growing on the edge of the entire sidewalk and the front door.
Seriously, man! If the management can't keep the outside litter-free and thr landscape from growing out of control, I wonder how the kitchen looks.
Brian Schn
-
July 06, 2026
The food was good and the service was great. I just got a take out order. The crazy issue is the price of food! $47 for a pizza and 9 wings? This price is crazy expensive. How much has your food gone up in the last 10 years? 70%??? This message is more directed at the corporate office. I just hope everyone that works there is being paid $20+ the price is not there fault. Thank you to the actual workers who run this location.
James O’Brien
-
June 21, 2026
Start to finish it was a disappointment. Never been here before. Was quickly seated bathroom was clean so that was good. Waiter brought mozzarella sticks even tho we ordered pretzel sticks and talked about honey mustard at length. Those pretzel sticks were cold in the center when they did come out. Ordered a large supreme hand tossed pizza and a Mac and cheese for my daughter. The pizza wasn't cooked properly it turned to dough when picked up. It was like chewing mush. Wayy to mush sausage is what caused it imo. Won't be back it was a 2 outta 10. I can get Mac and cheese anywhere.
*update* I was sick all night starting about 15 mins after getting home. (Made my review while sitting in the restaurant)
NEVER AGAIN!
Emily Nelson
-
July 08, 2025
Really disappointed. Spent $33 on a pizza and couldn’t even eat all of it because there were huge bubbles which led to no toppings on several pieces. The insides of these pieces were completely hollow. Bubbles happen but for a $33 pizza and to have at least 25% of it inedible is kinda ridiculous. The fried pickles looked sloppy. Some pickles had a mountain of seasoning and some had none. The chips for our nachos were burnt and so was the kids pizza. Donut bites were chewy almost like they were stale. We ordered a ton of food and spent a good bit of money just to feel like they took all the food that wasn’t good enough for the dine in people.
Our Address
2495 S Oneida St, Green Bay, WI 54304, USA
Claim Listing: Old Chicago
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
The waitress was the only redeeming quality about this place that was holding it back from been a complete terrible visit. She was apologetic and ended up getting it removed from our bill, very nice lady. Our pizza was so thin it couldn't even be cooked properly, the dough already wasn't cooked thoroughly, still stretched apart and separated just trying to hold it. I'm not sure if there's a pizza sauce shortage but it looks like they put the thinnest layer possible on top of layer of crust that looked thinner than a dime. Our waitress was very apologetic, took it back to get it replaced which at first they just tried to reheat it, sending it back with everything on top burnt black but the dough was already a mess. They ended up making us a new one which was just as bad as the first. In the first two pictures you can see the dough separating, third picture being the teaspoon of sauce on top of playdough consistency base, the final two pictures show the paper thin pizza. (This was the replacement pizza since the first one was worse) Typically we have pretty good visits here too. But frozen pizza would top the stuff we were served any day.
I decided against this place after pulling pulling into the lot. I almost walked inside but noticed trash littered all over the sidewalk around the building and weeds growing on the edge of the entire sidewalk and the front door. Seriously, man! If the management can't keep the outside litter-free and thr landscape from growing out of control, I wonder how the kitchen looks.
The food was good and the service was great. I just got a take out order. The crazy issue is the price of food! $47 for a pizza and 9 wings? This price is crazy expensive. How much has your food gone up in the last 10 years? 70%??? This message is more directed at the corporate office. I just hope everyone that works there is being paid $20+ the price is not there fault. Thank you to the actual workers who run this location.
Start to finish it was a disappointment. Never been here before. Was quickly seated bathroom was clean so that was good. Waiter brought mozzarella sticks even tho we ordered pretzel sticks and talked about honey mustard at length. Those pretzel sticks were cold in the center when they did come out. Ordered a large supreme hand tossed pizza and a Mac and cheese for my daughter. The pizza wasn't cooked properly it turned to dough when picked up. It was like chewing mush. Wayy to mush sausage is what caused it imo. Won't be back it was a 2 outta 10. I can get Mac and cheese anywhere. *update* I was sick all night starting about 15 mins after getting home. (Made my review while sitting in the restaurant) NEVER AGAIN!
Really disappointed. Spent $33 on a pizza and couldn’t even eat all of it because there were huge bubbles which led to no toppings on several pieces. The insides of these pieces were completely hollow. Bubbles happen but for a $33 pizza and to have at least 25% of it inedible is kinda ridiculous. The fried pickles looked sloppy. Some pickles had a mountain of seasoning and some had none. The chips for our nachos were burnt and so was the kids pizza. Donut bites were chewy almost like they were stale. We ordered a ton of food and spent a good bit of money just to feel like they took all the food that wasn’t good enough for the dine in people.